Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
ForumsPrimary Games Discussion › 'Dead or Alive fans demanded larger brea ...

General Games Discussion has a new name! Primary Games Discussion forum is the place to discuss all matters of the gaming world, be it the platforms, latest in industry news, or even gaming music and movies!

Rules:

- Follow the Terms of Use and read the FAQ.
- Be respectful and you'll be respected in return.
- No discussion of illegal activities.
- Cross-Platform debates belong in the System Wars forum

'Dead or Alive fans demanded larger breasts' says DoA5 director

Forum Actions
  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 13994
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 1:48 pm GMT
    MrGeezer wrote:
    DOA is not predicated on breasts.

    Indeed it isn't, but its marketing revolves around them



    Can't remember the title of a game? Ask us in the Game Remembrance Thread
    Over 200 resolved queries

    [QUOTE="MrGeezer"]DOA is not predicated on breasts.[/QUOTE] Indeed it isn't, but its marketing revolves around them
  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 2:21 pm GMT

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:
    MrGeezer wrote:
    DOA is not predicated on breasts.
    Indeed it isn't, but its marketing revolves around them

    I'm not aware of any such marketing as it pertains to DOA5. I do recall a commercial for one of the earlier games with some guys getting all worked up at the Ninja ladies kicking high but that was clearly toungue in cheek.

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"][QUOTE="MrGeezer"]DOA is not predicated on breasts.[/QUOTE] Indeed it isn't, but its marketing revolves around them[/QUOTE]

    I'm not aware of any such marketing as it pertains to DOA5. I do recall a commercial for one of the earlier games with some guys getting all worked up at the Ninja ladies kicking high but that was clearly toungue in cheek.

  • Level 17
    Minus World
    Posts: 237
    Oct 3, 2012 2:29 pm GMT

    MrGeezer wrote:
    PolygonBust wrote:

    MrGeezer wrote:
    See, here's the thing. Even people who only play Dead or Alive for the boobs won't admit it. They'll say it's for the gameplay, and that boobs are just a nice bonus...

    Why do you care so much about shame when buying a videogame that is sexualized, but not other forms of (sometimes even more explicit) media? What if you genuinely find the DoA and Beach volleyball games fun to play? Should you still feel ashamed for enjoying them?

    I really think your out of line judging people on such purchases. You have no idea what that person is like, why assume that they have some kind of mental disorder where they find pixelated characters "attractive" but not real life human beings? If I find a game is fun/original/appealing, I'm going to buy it. Doesn't matter if the person behind the counter thinks I'm a lonley virgin buying a game like DoA or a hopeless nerd buying Skyrim. At the end of the day I'm still a much more accomplished person than the deadbeat working at Walmart.

    Have you ever heard of this thing where people ordering porn in hotels got fed up about their purchases being listed on the bill, so lots of hotels actually changed that? Alternatively, have you heard of that thing that's been done in lots of places where guys arrested for buying hookers had their names plastered in the local paper and then prostitution actually went down? Yeah...an actual criminal record wasn't enough to stop them. But being outed in the community as a dude who's pathetic enough to actually hire a hooker? That did it. And while we're at it, why do people wear nice looking clothes instead of walking around in pants that are riddled with moth holes and shirts that are stained with ketchup?

    You gotta be pretty naive to think that most people aren't into that kind of thing. We're human, we have drives. As long as your not hurting someone else in the process, what's the harm in playing/watching sexually explicit material?

    And why do people act like DoA is the only fighting game with scantly-clad women? MK, SF, SC, KoF all have at least a few sexuallized female fighters; yet you don't treat their fanbases with the same disdain do you?

    Edited on Oct 3, 2012 2:30 pm GMT

    [QUOTE="MrGeezer"][QUOTE="PolygonBust"]

    [QUOTE="MrGeezer"] See, here's the thing. Even people who only play Dead or Alive for the boobs [i]won't admit it[/i]. They'll say it's for the gameplay, and that boobs are just a nice bonus...[/QUOTE]

    Why do you care so much about shame when buying a videogame that is sexualized, but not other forms of (sometimes even more explicit) media? What if you genuinely find the DoA and Beach volleyball games fun to play? Should you still feel ashamed for enjoying them?

    I really think your out of line judging people on such purchases. You have no idea what that person is like, why assume that they have some kind of mental disorder where they find pixelated characters "attractive" but not real life human beings? If I find a game is fun/original/appealing, I'm going to buy it. Doesn't matter if the person behind the counter thinks I'm a lonley virgin buying a game like DoA or a hopeless nerd buying Skyrim. At the end of the day I'm still a much more accomplished person than the deadbeat working at Walmart.

    [/QUOTE] Have you ever heard of this thing where people ordering porn in hotels got fed up about their purchases being listed on the bill, so lots of hotels actually changed that? Alternatively, have you heard of that thing that's been done in lots of places where guys arrested for buying hookers had their names plastered in the local paper and then [i]prostitution actually went down[/i]? Yeah...an actual criminal record wasn't enough to stop them. But being outed in the community as a dude who's pathetic enough to actually hire a hooker? That did it. And while we're at it, why do people wear nice looking clothes instead of walking around in pants that are riddled with moth holes and shirts that are stained with ketchup?[/QUOTE]

    You gotta be pretty naive to think that most people aren't into that kind of thing. We're human, we have drives. As long as your not hurting someone else in the process, what's the harm in playing/watching sexually explicit material?

    And why do people act like DoA is the only fighting game with scantly-clad women? MK, SF, SC, KoF all have at least a few sexuallized female fighters; yet you don't treat their fanbases with the same disdain do you?

  • Level 67
    I Am Error
    Posts: 16448
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 2:53 pm GMT

    Tecmo needs a PR guy to ride herd on the director in future interviews. Talk about DOA's breasts has superceded talk about the newly released DOA5.

    Tecmo needs a PR guy to ride herd on the director in future interviews. Talk about DOA's breasts has superceded talk about the newly released DOA5.

  • Level 67
    I Am Error
    Posts: 54520
    Oct 3, 2012 3:00 pm GMT
    PolygonBust wrote:
    You gotta be pretty naive to think that most people aren't into that kind of thing. We're human, we have drives. As long as your not hurting someone else in the process, what's the harm in playing/watching sexually explicit material?


    Because if someone wants sexually explicit material, they like to think that they can do a little bit better than paying $60 for what's essentially "porno for 12 year old boys". Not that I even think that DoA even is "porno for 12 year old boys" (the beach volleyball games are another matter).

    Going back to the comic book example, have you even seen some of the stuff that makes its way onto covers? It's ridiculous. Regardless of why you're buying it (let's assume you're buying it for the story), the people drawing the comic don't think so. The people making it clearly think you just have the mentality of a 12 year old boy who is buying comic books for the boobs, and that's a little bit offensive. Anyone who sees you reading it is gonna think the exact same thing about you, because how can they not? Regardless of if it's true, reading that stuff affects your image in a certain way, and what it's saying about you as a person is not a good thing. Again, don't pretend like image doesn't matter. Lots of people like porn, sure. But given the choice between secretly finding it online vs having to actually be seen walking into a store to buy it, what do you think people are going to choose? Yeah yeah, everyone looks at porn. But most people don't leave their porn DVDs in plain view in the living room, and they go to extra lengths to hide the weird poop-fetish stuff. And yeah, I agree that the sexuality in DoA gets exaggerated. Doesn't matter, the perception exists. The fact is that people don't bring up the "you're a pervert" argument if you start talking about Mortal Kombat or Tekken, while that sort of thing does get brought up with regards to Dead or Alive. Is that fair? No, but that doesn't change the attitudes that people have about it.
    [QUOTE="PolygonBust"]You gotta be pretty naive to think that most people aren't into that kind of thing. We're human, we have drives. As long as your not hurting someone else in the process, what's the harm in playing/watching sexually explicit material?[/QUOTE] Because if someone wants sexually explicit material, they like to think that they can do a little bit better than paying $60 for what's essentially "porno for 12 year old boys". Not that I even think that DoA even is "porno for 12 year old boys" (the beach volleyball games are another matter). Going back to the comic book example, have you even [i]seen[/i] some of the stuff that makes its way onto covers? It's ridiculous. Regardless of why you're buying it (let's assume you're buying it for the story), the people [i]drawing[/i] the comic don't think so. The people [i]making it[/i] clearly think you just have the mentality of a 12 year old boy who is buying comic books for the boobs, and that's a little bit offensive. Anyone who sees you reading it is gonna think the exact same thing about you, because how can they not? Regardless of if it's true, reading that stuff affects [i]your[/i] image in a certain way, and what it's saying about you as a person [i]is not a good thing[/i]. Again, don't pretend like image doesn't matter. Lots of people like porn, sure. But given the choice between secretly finding it online vs having to actually be seen walking into a store to buy it, what do you think people are going to choose? Yeah yeah, everyone looks at porn. But most people don't leave their porn DVDs in plain view in the living room, and they go to extra lengths to hide the weird poop-fetish stuff. And yeah, I agree that the sexuality in DoA gets exaggerated. Doesn't matter, the perception exists. The fact is that people [i]don't[/i] bring up the "you're a pervert" argument if you start talking about Mortal Kombat or Tekken, while that sort of thing [i]does[/i] get brought up with regards to Dead or Alive. Is that fair? No, but that doesn't change the attitudes that people have about it.
  • Level 70
    The Boss
    Posts: 14266
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 3:04 pm GMT
    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:

    I wanted to add that the amount of blanket insults being hurled at people who play this franchise is disgusting.

    I fully understand that many of the base life forms that dwell on the web require a diet rich in derision and hostility to buoy their sense of worth but even by Internet standards some of the illogicality on display here is staggering.

    There is nothing in DOA5 that is any more provocative than what can be observed in any number of other popular franchises, both within and outside of the genre.

    And an extra shout-out to the bigots who felt the need to slander the entirety of Japanese culture based on a video game and some anime.

    Very, very classy.

    I couldn't agree more. Some very ridiculous comments in this thread indeed and I'd also wager are likely hypocritical as well.

    [QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]

    I wanted to add that the amount of blanket insults being hurled at people who play this franchise is disgusting.

    I fully understand that many of the base life forms that dwell on the web require a diet rich in derision and hostility to buoy their sense of worth but even by Internet standards some of the illogicality on display here is staggering.

    There is nothing in DOA5 that is any more provocative than what can be observed in any number of other popular franchises, both within and outside of the genre.

    And an extra shout-out to the bigots who felt the need to slander the entirety of Japanese culture based on a video game and some anime.

    Very, very classy.

    [/QUOTE]I couldn't agree more. Some very ridiculous comments in this thread indeed and I'd also wager are likely hypocritical as well.
  • Level 20
    Metal Slime
    Posts: 764
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 8:56 pm GMT

    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:

    I wanted to add that the amount of blanket insults being hurled at people who play this franchise is disgusting.

    I fully understand that many of the base life forms that dwell on the web require a diet rich in derision and hostility to buoy their sense of worth but even by Internet standards some of the illogicality on display here is staggering.

    There is nothing in DOA5 that is any more provocative than what can be observed in any number of other popular franchises, both within and outside of the genre.

    And an extra shout-out to the bigots who felt the need to slander the entirety of Japanese culture based on a video game and some anime.

    Very, very classy.

    Cool your jets a bit. You've been known to hurl a few insults yourself.

    I don't like bigotry, either, so I'm no more fond of blanket criticisms of Japanese culture than you are, but there are fundamental differences that can't be ignored, either. Japanese culture is extremely sexist and ethnocentric, among other things, and it influences the media products that are developed there. I've gotten the impression that fans of games like this don't have a lot of empathy for people on the short end of human rights issues, but Japan certainly deserves a lot of criticism for its collective lack of compassion in that regard.

    You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.

    Edited on Oct 3, 2012 8:58 pm GMT

    [QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]

    I wanted to add that the amount of blanket insults being hurled at people who play this franchise is disgusting.

    I fully understand that many of the base life forms that dwell on the web require a diet rich in derision and hostility to buoy their sense of worth but even by Internet standards some of the illogicality on display here is staggering.

    There is nothing in DOA5 that is any more provocative than what can be observed in any number of other popular franchises, both within and outside of the genre.

    And an extra shout-out to the bigots who felt the need to slander the entirety of Japanese culture based on a video game and some anime.

    Very, very classy.

    [/QUOTE]

    Cool your jets a bit. You've been known to hurl a few insults yourself.

    I don't like bigotry, either, so I'm no more fond of blanket criticisms of Japanese culture than you are, but there are fundamental differences that can't be ignored, either. Japanese culture is extremely sexist and ethnocentric, among other things, and it influences the media products that are developed there. I've gotten the impression that fans of games like this don't have a lot of empathy for people on the short end of human rights issues, but Japan certainly deserves a lot of criticism for its collective lack of compassion in that regard.

    You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.

  • Level 37
    Heiankyo Alien
    Posts: 4209
    User is Online
    Oct 3, 2012 11:00 pm GMT
    capaho wrote:
    You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.

    Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series.



    El ZoRRo vs Omega Prime! Witness the epic battle yourself! Who was right? Lord only knows(well, Him and anyone who finished the ninth grade...)

    My gaming blog and a different kind of videogame review.

    "No, no, no. Amateur! Lie down before you hurt yourself..." -- Timon
    [QUOTE="capaho"]You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.[/QUOTE] Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series.
  • Level 20
    Metal Slime
    Posts: 764
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 3:06 am GMT

    El_Zo1212o wrote:
    Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series.

    The mechanics are not relevant to the specific implications of the imagery.

    [QUOTE="El_Zo1212o"] Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series. [/QUOTE]

    The mechanics are not relevant to the specific implications of the imagery.

  • Level 38
    DJ Boy
    Posts: 4622
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 8:49 am GMT

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:

    http://www.gamesradar.com/dead-or-alive-director-fans-demanded-larger-breasts/

    Tecmo and Team Ninja realized they crossed the line a little bit concerning the sexualization of female fighters in their Dead or Alive series. This is why they decided to reduce the amount of boobage in the upcoming DoA5, a trend already visible in the demo included with Ninja Gaiden 3... except fans revolted against the decision; game director Shimbori is quoted saying:

    "We actually got a lot of feedback from people who were playing the demo, saying, 'We want bigger breasts. Make the characters more like that.' That was kind of surprising."

    Reverse gears, Team Ninja and crank up the cleavage slider, becausethat's it, let's just stop pretending people play this series for the gameplay or the fighting technique: fans flat out screamed they are in for the boobs and they expect the sexiness level to increase with every iteration of the game.

    Of course there will be some exceptions to this rule, but when a developer feels the need to make a U-turn based on player feedback it means an overwhelming majority of them agreed on the point.



    So Dead or Alive 6 will have a Button for Punches, one for Kicks, one for Blocking, one for Throws and a fifth one to control the breasts of the female fighters xD Jeez, those move sets will look interesting

    Kaz

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"]

    http://www.gamesradar.com/dead-or-alive-director-fans-demanded-larger-breasts/

    Tecmo and Team Ninja realized they crossed the line a little bit concerning the sexualization of female fighters in their Dead or Alive series. This is why they decided to reduce the amount of boobage in the upcoming DoA5, a trend already visible in the demo included with Ninja Gaiden 3... except fans revolted against the decision; game director Shimbori is quoted saying:

    "We actually got a lot of feedback from people who were playing the demo, saying, 'We want bigger breasts. Make the characters more like that.' That was kind of surprising."

    Reverse gears, Team Ninja and crank up the cleavage slider, becausethat's it, let's just stop pretending people play this series for the gameplay or the fighting technique: fans flat out screamed they are in for the boobs and they expect the sexiness level to increase with every iteration of the game.

    Of course there will be some exceptions to this rule, but when a developer feels the need to make a U-turn based on player feedback it means an overwhelming majority of them agreed on the point.

    [/QUOTE]

    So Dead or Alive 6 will have a Button for Punches, one for Kicks, one for Blocking, one for Throws and a fifth one to control the breasts of the female fighters xD Jeez, those move sets will look interesting :D

  • Level 25
    Defias Brotherhood
    Posts: 542
    Oct 4, 2012 8:57 am GMT

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 13994
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 9:08 am GMT
    NaturalDisplay wrote:

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?


    Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence.

    That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point



    Can't remember the title of a game? Ask us in the Game Remembrance Thread
    Over 200 resolved queries

    [QUOTE="NaturalDisplay"]

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    [/QUOTE] Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence. That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point
  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 9:12 am GMT

    capaho wrote:

    Cool your jets a bit. You've been known to hurl a few insults yourself.

    I don't like bigotry, either, so I'm no more fond of blanket criticisms of Japanese culture than you are, but there are fundamental differences that can't be ignored, either. Japanese culture is extremely sexist and ethnocentric, among other things, and it influences the media products that are developed there. I've gotten the impression that fans of games like this don't have a lot of empathy for people on the short end of human rights issues, but Japan certainly deserves a lot of criticism for its collective lack of compassion in that regard.

    You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.

    I don't need to cool my jets.

    I'd rather just curb stomp your vapid arguments into the ground.

    The criticisms you levy against Japan could rightly and logically be levied against just about any other nation on this planet.

    That cute little buzzword, ethnocentric, is the defining principle of most nations and their governments and manifests in various ways, from imperialistic tendencies to smaller nations playing passive-aggressive political games or funding terrorism.

    So that particular rationale is too broad and vague to be of any viable use as justification for your blatant racism.

    Also, ethnocentricity has nothing to do with gender inequality.

    Japan does have a pronounced history of institutionalized gender inequality but again, that is hardly a unique cultural distinction. The oppression of females in various Middle Eastern nations is not merely predicated on social norms but is often clearly mandated and enforceable. And let us not forget that Europe and the U.S. also enjoy a protracted history of inequality; American women couldn't even vote until 1920.

    So again, that criticism hardly makes Japan unique.

    As to the notion that people who enjoy these types of games are somehow insensitive to issues of social inequality, even by your ridiculous logic such an assertion is a stretch. I've spent years working with people on the lowest ends of the social spectrum even while pseudo-intellectuals like you thump on your chest in an effort to prove your enlightened superiority. (When you're not slandering an entire race of people that is)

    Unlike you and many others in this thread, I've played the game because I'm a genre enthusiast and because DOA5 is a legitimately great game. It's also not all that provocative; certainly no worse than any number of other games on the market.

    What you wrote about Japanese culture was bigoted garbage and rather than admit the fallacy of your comments or simply let the issue die you decided to step up to me and explain that not only was your ignorant slander justified but also that I'm the real bigot because I play the game.

    Please keep challenging me Capho because frankly, I could bust up your pitiful arguments indefinitely.

    Edited on Oct 4, 2012 10:04 am GMT

    [QUOTE="capaho"]

    Cool your jets a bit. You've been known to hurl a few insults yourself.

    I don't like bigotry, either, so I'm no more fond of blanket criticisms of Japanese culture than you are, but there are fundamental differences that can't be ignored, either. Japanese culture is extremely sexist and ethnocentric, among other things, and it influences the media products that are developed there. I've gotten the impression that fans of games like this don't have a lot of empathy for people on the short end of human rights issues, but Japan certainly deserves a lot of criticism for its collective lack of compassion in that regard.

    You may not be able to see it yourself, but images like the ones featured in this game do not represent a drooling, knuckle-dragging good time to all of us.

    [/QUOTE]

    I don't need to cool my jets.

    I'd rather just curb stomp your vapid arguments into the ground.

    The criticisms you levy against Japan could rightly and logically be levied against just about any other nation on this planet.

    That cute little buzzword, ethnocentric, is the defining principle of most nations and their governments and manifests in various ways, from imperialistic tendencies to smaller nations playing passive-aggressive political games or funding terrorism.

    So that particular rationale is too broad and vague to be of any viable use as justification for your blatant racism.

    Also, ethnocentricity has nothing to do with gender inequality.

    Japan does have a pronounced history of institutionalized gender inequality but again, that is hardly a unique cultural distinction. The oppression of females in various Middle Eastern nations is not merely predicated on social norms but is often clearly mandated and enforceable. And let us not forget that Europe and the U.S. also enjoy a protracted history of inequality; American women couldn't even vote until 1920.

    So again, that criticism hardly makes Japan unique.

    As to the notion that people who enjoy these types of games are somehow insensitive to issues of social inequality, even by your ridiculous logic such an assertion is a stretch. I've spent years working with people on the lowest ends of the social spectrum even while pseudo-intellectuals like you thump on your chest in an effort to prove your enlightened superiority. (When you're not slandering an entire race of people that is)

    Unlike you and many others in this thread, I've played the game because I'm a genre enthusiast and because DOA5 is a legitimately great game. It's also not all that provocative; certainly no worse than any number of other games on the market.

    What you wrote about Japanese culture was bigoted garbage and rather than admit the fallacy of your comments or simply let the issue die you decided to step up to me and explain that not only was your ignorant slander justified but also that I'm the real bigot because I play the game.

    Please keep challenging me Capho because frankly, I could bust up your pitiful arguments indefinitely.

  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 9:33 am GMT

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:
    NaturalDisplay wrote:

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence. That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point

    That seems like an unnecessary cheap shot coming from somebody who should know better.

    The reality, as I've stated before, is that DOA5 is no worse than any number of other games. I do think the developers were foolish to cater to that particular request but in all honestly the game moves at such a blistering pace that it isn't very noticeable.

    And the ladies aren't dressed any more provocatively than the women of Tekken, SF, SC, etc.

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"][QUOTE="NaturalDisplay"]

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    [/QUOTE] Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence. That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point[/QUOTE]

    That seems like an unnecessary cheap shot coming from somebody who should know better.

    The reality, as I've stated before, is that DOA5 is no worse than any number of other games. I do think the developers were foolish to cater to that particular request but in all honestly the game moves at such a blistering pace that it isn't very noticeable.

    And the ladies aren't dressed any more provocatively than the women of Tekken, SF, SC, etc.

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 13994
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 9:54 am GMT
    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:
    NaturalDisplay wrote:

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence. That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point

    That seems like an unnecessary cheap shot coming from somebody who should know better.

    The reality, as I've stated before, is that DOA5 is no worse than any number of other games. I do think the developers were foolish to cater to that particular request but in all honestly the game moves at such a blistering pace that it isn't very noticeable.

    And the ladies aren't dressed any more provocatively than the women of Tekken, SF, SC, etc.


    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise.

    Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.



    Can't remember the title of a game? Ask us in the Game Remembrance Thread
    Over 200 resolved queries

    [QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"][QUOTE="NaturalDisplay"]

    Wow, the amount of hate towards sexualisation in this thread is astonishing. What is wrong with a little booby-looking once in a while?

    [/QUOTE] Nothing per se, but sexualisation caters to the lowest, most basic human instincts and too much of it is an insult to your intelligence. That said, one look at your gamercard and see you will never agree with me on this point[/QUOTE]

    That seems like an unnecessary cheap shot coming from somebody who should know better.

    The reality, as I've stated before, is that DOA5 is no worse than any number of other games. I do think the developers were foolish to cater to that particular request but in all honestly the game moves at such a blistering pace that it isn't very noticeable.

    And the ladies aren't dressed any more provocatively than the women of Tekken, SF, SC, etc.

    [/QUOTE] It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.
  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 10:02 am GMT

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"]

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    [/QUOTE]

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.

  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 10:29 am GMT

    capaho wrote:

    El_Zo1212o wrote:
    Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series.

    The mechanics are not relevant to the specific implications of the imagery.

    And what are the specific implications of the imagery in this game you clearly haven't played?

    Please explain, in detail, what these images imply and how they contribute harmfully to the social segregation and inequality of women.

    [QUOTE="capaho"]

    [QUOTE="El_Zo1212o"] Gram's been arguing that the mechanics of the game, and specifically not the imagery, is what draws fans of the series. [/QUOTE]

    The mechanics are not relevant to the specific implications of the imagery.

    [/QUOTE]

    And what are the specific implications of the imagery in this game you clearly haven't played?

    Please explain, in detail, what these images imply and how they contribute harmfully to the social segregation and inequality of women.

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 13994
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 11:14 am GMT
    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.


    I have played 1, 2 and 4, I have no interest in 5.

    That aside, don't get stuck on DoA, I'm making a more general statement here



    Can't remember the title of a game? Ask us in the Game Remembrance Thread
    Over 200 resolved queries

    [QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"]

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    [/QUOTE]

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.

    [/QUOTE] I have played 1, 2 and 4, I have no interest in 5. That aside, don't get stuck on DoA, I'm making a more general statement here
  • Level 44
    Violence Fight
    Posts: 7148
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 12:25 pm GMT

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:
    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:

    Black_Knight_00 wrote:

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.

    I have played 1, 2 and 4, I have no interest in 5. That aside, don't get stuck on DoA, I'm making a more general statement here

    We don't have to focus on DOA5 at all.

    By your rationale I can assume you find violence equally objectionable as it too caters to a more base and primal human fascination with the taboo of death, dismemberment, etc.

    It certainly occupies no higher intellectual strata than sexuality.

    Yet you don't seem at all repelled by games featuring copious violence, which could be argued as hypocritical or, at the very least, logically inconsistent.

    That isn't an insult but rather an observation because you seem offended by the paltry titillations present in DOA5 yet I don't see you reeling from the overtly violent images present in many of the games you play and have subsequently ranked.

    It all seems a tad...selective.

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"][QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]

    [QUOTE="Black_Knight_00"]

    It wasn't meant as an insult, I simply said that his gamercard implies he thinks differently, which is legitimate. Up to him now to tell me otherwise. Also, I don't limit my reasoning to DoA, it goes without saying that sex is a cheap selling point no matter the game/media in general that abuses it.

    [/QUOTE]

    DOA5's selling point is the fighting engine, which is vastly improved.

    And personally I'm not convinced that overt sexual content is an effective business strategy as it pertains to an already somewhat niche genre. I think with the DOA Volleyball games you could make that assertion but with a dedicated fighter, not so much.

    You seem to be going very far out of your way to dismiss this game based on this one interview from the developer.

    Have you played the game?

    Because I get the sense that most of the detractors have not.

    [/QUOTE] I have played 1, 2 and 4, I have no interest in 5. That aside, don't get stuck on DoA, I'm making a more general statement here[/QUOTE]

    We don't have to focus on DOA5 at all.

    By your rationale I can assume you find violence equally objectionable as it too caters to a more base and primal human fascination with the taboo of death, dismemberment, etc.

    It certainly occupies no higher intellectual strata than sexuality.

    Yet you don't seem at all repelled by games featuring copious violence, which could be argued as hypocritical or, at the very least, logically inconsistent.

    That isn't an insult but rather an observation because you seem offended by the paltry titillations present in DOA5 yet I don't see you reeling from the overtly violent images present in many of the games you play and have subsequently ranked.

    It all seems a tad...selective.

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 13994
    User is Online
    Oct 4, 2012 1:09 pm GMT
    Grammaton-Cleric wrote:
    We don't have to focus on DOA5 at all.

    By your rationale I can assume you find violence equally objectionable as it too caters to a more base and primal human fascination with the taboo of death, dismemberment, etc.

    It certainly occupies no higher intellectual strata than sexuality.

    Yet you don't seem at all repelled by games featuring copious violence, which could be argued as hypocritical or, at the very least, logically inconsistent.

    That isn't an insult but rather an observation because you seem offended by the paltry titillations present in DOA5 yet I don't see you reeling from the overtly violent images present in many of the games you play and have subsequently ranked.

    It all seems a tad...selective.

    Actually it's a more complicate matter than that. I have spoken against gratuitous violence as well, I have also spoken in defense of it. Violence can be a catharsis feeding the natural instinct of domination or it can be something sick and completely distasteful. The keyword here is "context": there are games where violence is complementary and cathartic, while in others it's an end in itself.

    The line is much less blurry when it comes to sex: you can represent a woman as a person (say, Lightning from FFXIII or the new Lara Croft) or you can represent her as a walking excuse for huge bouncing boobs (Dead or Alive, Soul Calibur, Ninja Gaiden, Bayonetta, even Heavy Rain). You can make her act like a person or you can give her a constantly alluring and flirtatious personality.

    You ask if this offends me. It does, but not the way you may think: I could care less about the sexual content per se. What bothers me is what's behind it: this undying bilateral gender stereotype which wants women to be either buxom sluts or preteen schoolgirls in skimpy outfits and male gamers to perceive this as added value to a game. I feel like they expect us to increase our interest in the game on account of the sexual content and this is an insult to our intelligence.

    Then there's the feminine point of view: we have plenty of fantastic male protagonists, but you don't need two hands to count female leads who actually look and act like people and not something out of a japanese softcore magazine. In other words: we are not horny teens and we don't need cheap sexual stimulation from our videogames. What we need are female characters we can actually look at and respect for a change.



    Can't remember the title of a game? Ask us in the Game Remembrance Thread
    Over 200 resolved queries

    [QUOTE="Grammaton-Cleric"]We don't have to focus on DOA5 at all. By your rationale I can assume you find violence equally objectionable as it too caters to a more base and primal human fascination with the taboo of death, dismemberment, etc. It certainly occupies no higher intellectual strata than sexuality. Yet you don't seem at all repelled by games featuring copious violence, which could be argued as hypocritical or, at the very least, logically inconsistent. That isn't an insult but rather an observation because you seem offended by the paltry titillations present in DOA5 yet I don't see you reeling from the overtly violent images present in many of the games you play and have subsequently ranked. It all seems a tad...selective.[/QUOTE] Actually it's a more complicate matter than that. I have spoken against gratuitous violence as well, I have also spoken in defense of it. Violence can be a catharsis feeding the natural instinct of domination or it can be something sick and completely distasteful. The keyword here is "context": there are games where violence is complementary and cathartic, while in others it's an end in itself. The line is much less blurry when it comes to sex: you can represent a woman as a [i]person[/i] (say, Lightning from FFXIII or the new Lara Croft) or you can represent her as a walking excuse for huge bouncing boobs (Dead or Alive, Soul Calibur, Ninja Gaiden, Bayonetta, even Heavy Rain). You can make her act like a [i]person[/i] or you can give her a constantly alluring and flirtatious personality. You ask if this offends me. It does, but not the way you may think: I could care less about the sexual content per se. What bothers me is what's behind it: this undying bilateral gender stereotype which wants women to be either buxom sluts or preteen schoolgirls in skimpy outfits and male gamers to perceive this as added value to a game. I feel like they expect us to increase our interest in the game on account of the sexual content and this is an insult to our intelligence. Then there's the feminine point of view: we have plenty of fantastic male protagonists, but you don't need two hands to count female leads who actually look and act like [i]people[/i] and not something out of a japanese softcore magazine. In other words: we are not horny teens and we don't need cheap sexual stimulation from our videogames. What we need are female characters we can actually look at and [i]respect[/i] for a change.
Forum Actions
ForumsPrimary Games Discussion › 'Dead or Alive fans demanded larger brea ...