Search
Search
Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
Forums › GameSpot Competitions & Activities › Chalk Talk: Reviewer Revelry - Entrants

This forum is dedicated to GameSpot Competitions and Activities. Here you’ll find discussions about community events contests, sweepstakes, live competitions or union related contests or tournaments.

Chalk Talk: Reviewer Revelry - Entrants

Forum Actions
New Message
  • Synthia
     
    Level 46
    Mutoid Man
    Posts: 3421
    GameSpot staff memberBoard Admin
    User is Online
    Oct 5, 2012 2:31 pm GMT

    Video game reviews. Sometimes we love them; sometimes we hate them, sometimes we are confused and confounded by their logic when it comes to the games we love as well as the games that we thought were absolute trash. This weeks Chalk Talk we're going to spend some time reflecting on the art of the game review. Need some inspiration?

    Talk about your process when it comes to reviewing games, perhaps you wish to talk about how amazing you think reviews are and how important they are to our industry, or even talk about how terrible they can be and what a bad review means for the community. Special thanks to GameSpotters -Saigo- and Supermassive20 for suggesting this weeks topic!

    Be sure to mark your blog as editorial and sound off in this roll call thread here with your awesome Chalk Talk entry.

    Deadline to post a link to your Chalk Talk Submission is FRIDAY October 12 at 10:00am PT

    A few additional things to remember about your Chalk Talk Submission:
    - Entries must be aminimum of 500 words.
    - Do not use altered text fonts, colors, and be aware of your formatting.
    - Select at least one image to act as your "Cover Shot".
    -Mark your blog as EDITORIAL

    Edited on Oct 5, 2012 2:32 pm GMT

    #Social Share|Community News|#ChalkTalk

    Video game reviews. Sometimes we love them; sometimes we hate them, sometimes we are confused and confounded by their logic when it comes to the games we love as well as the games that we thought were absolute trash. This weeks Chalk Talk we're going to spend some time reflecting on the art of the game review. Need some inspiration?

    Talk about your process when it comes to reviewing games, perhaps you wish to talk about how amazing you think reviews are and how important they are to our industry, or even talk about how terrible they can be and what a bad review means for the community. Special thanks to GameSpotters -Saigo- and Supermassive20 for suggesting this weeks topic!

    Be sure to mark your blog as editorial and sound off in this roll call thread here with your awesome Chalk Talk entry.

    Deadline to post a link to your Chalk Talk Submission is FRIDAY October 12 at 10:00am PT

    A few additional things to remember about your Chalk Talk Submission:
    - Entries must be aminimum of 500 words.
    - Do not use altered text fonts, colors, and be aware of your formatting.
    - Select at least one image to act as your "Cover Shot".
    -Mark your blog as EDITORIAL

    Report Abuse
  • Gelugon_baat
     
    Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 19639
    User is Online
    Oct 5, 2012 5:59 pm GMT

    Say, may I cite one of my older blog posts instead of writing a new one?

    UPDATE: Just in case there is a green-light for this, here it is. By the way, I re-visited it and added some other passages. Little to no updates for what is already there though.

    Edited on Oct 8, 2012 1:04 am GMT Edited 2 total times.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    All the ladies below (mostly drawn by a certain awesome but, for better or worse, not-so-well known fan artist) are actual game characters, though not (necessarily) THAT kind of games if you are thinking about those.

    Maybe you want to read this: POSSIBLE BAIT & SWITCH IN TRIBES: ASCEND.

    Say, may I cite one of my older blog posts instead of writing a new one?

    UPDATE: Just in case there is a green-light for this, here it is. By the way, I re-visited it and added some other passages. Little to no updates for what is already there though.

    Report Abuse
  • Kravyn81
     
    Level 42
    Karnov
    Posts: 11976
    User is Online
    Oct 5, 2012 7:47 pm GMT
    This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it?
    Proud non-owner of any and all Apple products.
    This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it? ;)
    Report Abuse
  • NeonNinja
     
    Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 29274
    User is Online
    Oct 5, 2012 9:46 pm GMT

    Kravyn81 wrote:
    This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it?

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.

    Heirren wrote:
    Kojima puts 99% of modern cinema to shame.

    Some opinions are wrong. This is one of them.

    [QUOTE="Kravyn81"]This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it? ;)[/QUOTE]

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.

    Report Abuse
  • c_rake
     
    Level 72
    King of All Cosmos
    Posts: 14644
    Site moderatorBoard Moderator
    User is Online
    Oct 5, 2012 11:12 pm GMT

    Finally, a subject I'm well-versed in! Should be able to draft something easily.

    Finally, a subject I'm well-versed in! Should be able to draft something easily.

    Report Abuse
  • asian_pride69
     
    Level 58
    Death=Adder
    Posts: 20864
    Oct 5, 2012 11:48 pm GMT
    Ah, I might give this a try. I think I can cook up at least 500 words about this subject, though I've actually never written an editorial before. First time for everything, I guess?

    I can make no guarantees, though. I have chronic laziness

    Anime cafe, yo.
    Chie.
    My Reviews | Backlawggery | MAL

    Ah, I might give this a try. I think I can cook up at least 500 words about this subject, though I've actually never written an editorial before. First time for everything, I guess? I can make no guarantees, though. I have chronic laziness :P
    Report Abuse
  • Kravyn81
     
    Level 42
    Karnov
    Posts: 11976
    User is Online
    Oct 6, 2012 12:55 pm GMT
    NeonNinja wrote:

    Kravyn81 wrote:
    This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it?

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.


    Yes. How about we learn what it means when words are put in quotation marks before we get all huffy puffy, OK? Thank you.

    Back on topic: I have a submission coming soon, Synthia. Interestingly enough I wrote a blog about this back in March about why I think review scores are bad for games. I'm just going back and tweaking some things, cutting the fat, etc., but I should have it submitted by Monday
    Proud non-owner of any and all Apple products.
    [QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

    [QUOTE="Kravyn81"]This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it? ;)[/QUOTE]

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.

    [/QUOTE] Yes. How about we learn what it means when words are put in quotation marks before we get all huffy puffy, OK? Thank you. Back on topic: I have a submission coming soon, Synthia. Interestingly enough I wrote a blog about this back in March about why I think review scores are bad for games. I'm just going back and tweaking some things, cutting the fat, etc., but I should have it submitted by Monday :)
    Report Abuse
  • EvanescentCrow
     
    Level 10
    Phoenix Down
    Posts: 36
    Oct 7, 2012 3:23 am GMT
    First time doing something like this as well, so hopefully I fulfilled all the requirements with this entry.
    First time doing something like this as well, so hopefully I fulfilled all the requirements with [URL=http://www.gamespot.com/users/EvanescentCrow/show_blog_entry.php?topic_id=m-100-25995785]this[/URL] entry.
    Report Abuse
  • JBStone1981
     
    Level 15
    Nobunaga's Ambition
    Posts: 23
    User is Online
    Oct 8, 2012 10:46 pm GMT

    Try this on for size!

    Try this on for size!

    Report Abuse
  • g1rldraco7
     
    Level 55
    Rise From Your Grave
    Posts: 3097
    User is Online
    Oct 9, 2012 1:21 am GMT
    Hey I wanted to suggest a topic for Chalk Talk. DLC, does it really expand the experience or is it a waste of money and space on your console?
    Hey I wanted to suggest a topic for Chalk Talk. DLC, does it really expand the experience or is it a waste of money and space on your console?
    Report Abuse

  • Here's mine http://au.gamespot.com/users/ZanarkandTidus/show_blog_entry.php?topic_id=m-100-25995899#livefyre

    Report Abuse
  • NeonNinja
     
    Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 29274
    User is Online
    Oct 9, 2012 10:44 am GMT

    Kravyn81 wrote:
    NeonNinja wrote:

    Kravyn81 wrote:
    This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it?

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.

    Yes. How about we learn what it means when words are put in quotation marks before we get all huffy puffy, OK? Thank you. Back on topic: I have a submission coming soon, Synthia. Interestingly enough I wrote a blog about this back in March about why I think review scores are bad for games. I'm just going back and tweaking some things, cutting the fat, etc., but I should have it submitted by Monday

    Derpity derp. I'm agreeing with you, genius.

    Heirren wrote:
    Kojima puts 99% of modern cinema to shame.

    Some opinions are wrong. This is one of them.

    [QUOTE="Kravyn81"][QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

    [QUOTE="Kravyn81"]This wouldn't have anything to do with Kevin van Ord's recent "controversial" RE6 review and the community chatter about it, does it? ;)[/QUOTE]

    Controversial, my foot! Man gave out an honest review and the lowly peasants are pissy because he uses the full rating scale.

    [/QUOTE] Yes. How about we learn what it means when words are put in quotation marks before we get all huffy puffy, OK? Thank you. Back on topic: I have a submission coming soon, Synthia. Interestingly enough I wrote a blog about this back in March about why I think review scores are bad for games. I'm just going back and tweaking some things, cutting the fat, etc., but I should have it submitted by Monday :)[/QUOTE]

    Derpity derp. I'm agreeing with you, genius.

    Report Abuse

  • Blog engaged: http://www.gamespot.com/users/GeekyDad/show_blog_entry.php?topic_id=m-100-25995908

    Report Abuse
  • NeonNinja
     
    Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 29274
    User is Online
    Oct 9, 2012 11:52 am GMT

    Noble Neon tosses his hat into the ring.

    Let it be known that Words Take Precedence over Numbers

    Heirren wrote:
    Kojima puts 99% of modern cinema to shame.

    Some opinions are wrong. This is one of them.

    Noble Neon tosses his hat into the ring.

    Let it be known that Words Take Precedence over Numbers

    Report Abuse
  • benleslie5
     
    Level 66
    Secret Cow Level
    Posts: 16098
    Site Greeter
    User is Online
    Oct 9, 2012 2:03 pm GMT

    Here is my blog- A Review is a Review is it not

    GLF

    Here is my blog- A Review is a Review is it not

    Report Abuse
  • Starshine_M2A2
     
    Level 22
    Blaster Master
    Posts: 4036
    User is Online
    Oct 9, 2012 11:09 pm GMT

    Hi Synthia,

    My Blog's Up.

    Hi Synthia,

    My Blog's Up.

    Report Abuse
  • angelbless
     
    Level 56
    Mr. X
    Posts: 10472
    User is Online
    Oct 10, 2012 9:14 pm GMT

    I'm sorry for this Synthia, I admire you and the whole staff of GS with all my heart, but seeing the development of the Chalk Talk over these weeks, I cant help but feeling sad and disappointed to see that the reason my work was not recognized, wasnt because people could "complain" that the same users may be feature, specially after seeing that there are some users who have been featured for 3 consecutive weeks without objections and wihtout people complaininng about it.

    I am sorry that because of this fact I stopped writing for the Chalk Talk, as the 6-7 hours taken werent given any value, not even an "extra value". I'm sorry because I love to write....and was starting to really like writing for the Chalk Talk.

    I do not mind at all that the same users are featured over and over for several weeks, in fact I am very happy for him/her/them because all the articles have something interesting to learn from, what hurts me is that I wasnt given the same treatment/recognition, my effort wasnt valued and I was left behind.

    Sorry for all this, but I wanted to express myself.

    Thxs

    I'm sorry for this Synthia, I admire you and the whole staff of GS with all my heart, but seeing the development of the Chalk Talk over these weeks, I cant help but feeling sad and disappointed to see that the reason my work was not recognized, wasnt because people could "complain" that the same users may be feature, specially after seeing that there are some users who have been featured for 3 consecutive weeks without objections and wihtout people complaininng about it.

    I am sorry that because of this fact I stopped writing for the Chalk Talk, as the 6-7 hours taken werent given any value, not even an "extra value". I'm sorry because I love to write....and was starting to really like writing for the Chalk Talk.

    I do not mind at all that the same users are featured over and over for several weeks, in fact I am very happy for him/her/them because all the articles have something interesting to learn from, what hurts me is that I wasnt given the same treatment/recognition, my effort wasnt valued and I was left behind.

    Sorry for all this, but I wanted to express myself.

    Thxs

    Report Abuse
  • EvanescentCrow
     
    Level 10
    Phoenix Down
    Posts: 36
    Oct 11, 2012 3:58 am GMT
    angelbless wrote:
    I do not mind at all that the same users are featured over and over for several weeks, in fact I am very happy for him/her/them because all the articles have something interesting to learn from, what hurts me is that I wasnt given the same treatment/recognition, my effort wasnt valued and I was left behind.

    Not wanting to replace Synthia here, but I have a question, are you talking about Chalk Talk or Awesome User Blogs?

    If you mean AUB, I sort of agree. I'm not going to drop names, as that might hurt some feelings, but at least one of the latest blog entries is incredibly poor in both content and form, leading me to wonder who picked that to begin with as opposed to other very well written entries by other people.

    If you mean Chalk Talk, well, I'm new here (sort of) and have no idea how you get featured. I thought every entry was accepted, period, but correct me if I'm wrong.
    [QUOTE="angelbless"]I do not mind at all that the same users are featured over and over for several weeks, in fact I am very happy for him/her/them because all the articles have something interesting to learn from, what hurts me is that I wasnt given the same treatment/recognition, my effort wasnt valued and I was left behind.[/QUOTE] Not wanting to replace Synthia here, but I have a question, are you talking about Chalk Talk or Awesome User Blogs? If you mean AUB, I sort of agree. I'm not going to drop names, as that might hurt some feelings, but at least one of the latest blog entries is incredibly poor in both content and form, leading me to wonder who picked that to begin with as opposed to other very well written entries by other people. If you mean Chalk Talk, well, I'm new here (sort of) and have no idea how you get featured. I thought every entry was accepted, period, but correct me if I'm wrong.
    Report Abuse
  • Darthkaiser
     
    Level 58
    Death=Adder
    Posts: 13905
    Site moderatorBoard Moderator
    Oct 11, 2012 11:48 pm GMT

    I needed an excuse to make a blog anyway my editorial is ready hope it gets featured

    Edited on Oct 12, 2012 9:25 am GMT

    Simon

    Mod 11


    I needed an excuse to make a blog anyway my editorial is ready hope it gets featured

    Report Abuse
Forum Actions
New Message
Forums › GameSpot Competitions & Activities › Chalk Talk: Reviewer Revelry - Entrants