Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

Red Dead Redemption User Review

ipsofacto_93

It's a great game, but not what it's cracked up to be.

  • Posted Dec 27, 2012 1:01 pm GMT
Difficulty:
Just Right
Time Spent:
20 to 40 Hours
The Bottom Line:
"Don't believe the hype"
The game is good, but suffers from very repetitive story missions. There's lots to do, but it's all a bit laborious and, at times, I really felt I had to force myself to play. The problem isn't with the execution - the voice acting is phenomenal, the story helps you really relate to Marston (although it is pretty slow to start with) and whilst the shooting mechanics are a bit wobbly, they are very fun and simple to use. I think the problem is with the game itself. It just isn't always that enjoyable to play and when you're investing 20+ hours, it's a struggle sometimes to get through it. To put that into perspective, I've put in over 200 on Skyrim (I know...) and enjoyed every minute. It does pick up later in the game and whilst I really want to go and get the 100%, and I'm most of the way there, it's just going to be a grind I feel - and now I've completed it, I really can't bring myself to do it. It definitely is worth playing through just for the story though, if anything, and it isn't a bad game, just not as good as I expected.
I'm just playing Undead Nightmare and it's actually great. It's funny, lighthearted, and just genuine fun. Maybe it's down to personal opinion, but I'm having a lot more fun on this now.
Rate this Review:

More User Reviews

  1. You've done it again Rockstar. You've made me fall in love and forget to feed myself.

    Review Stats:
    • 6 out of 7 users agree with this review
  2. R* does it again!

    Review Stats:
    • 1 out of 10 users agrees with this review
  3. It's not better than GTA 4 or GTA SA, but it is one heck of a game nonetheless.

    Review Stats:
    • 2 out of 8 users agree with this review
  4. It's always good to see a western style game. This game delivers and it's fun to play.

    Review Stats:
    • 0 out of 2 users agree with this review
  5. While it is hampered by awkward controls, RDR delivers fun Western action.

    Review Stats:
    • 1 out of 2 users agrees with this review

Tell the world what you think of Red Dead Redemption.

User Videos

  1. Watch this video
    this is a glitch that happened to me when i was playing undead nightmare on my way back to fort mercer with my last missing persons quest
    Posted Aug 10, 2011
    by metalmasterW | 0:19 | 162 Views
  2. Watch this video
    The last game we played on Gamer Night #10(June 13, 2009) was Red Dead Revovler on Xbox. Match 4 is Norm vs. John(Me) P1 - Norm/Breaking_Silence/Christin a P2 - John/Da_Gamer/Red
    Posted Jul 1, 2009
    by dragon_king64 | 1:36 | 165 Views

User Images

  1. Red Dead Redemption New Screen
    Posted May 28, 2009
    by zeeshan810 | 375 Views
  2. Red Dead Redemption New Screen
    Posted May 28, 2009
    by zeeshan810 | 520 Views

Red Dead Redemption BoxshotEnlarge the boxshot
Not Following

    Game Stats

    Also on:

    Games You May Like

    Users who looked at content for this game also looked at these games.