Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty User Review
Leopard is crippled! Give it the boot (camp).
- Posted Jul 28, 2010 6:44 pm GMT
- Recommended by 3 of 10 users.
- Difficulty:
- Easy
- Time Spent:
- 10 Hours or Less
- The Bottom Line:
- "Broken"
Just don't even think about playing Starcraft II under OS X! As is so often the case, an outsourced port of a Direct X title to OpenGL and OS X has failed miserably.
I cannot speak for current generation hardware but for my previous generation MacBook Pro (the one with the silver bezel, just prior to the unibody switch) with 4GB of Ram and an 8600M GT video chip (which is admittedly the minimum specs for the mac) it is unplayable ... even at the LOWEST quality settings. Even if it didn't stutter and slow down so much, I wouldn't want to play it at the lowest quality settings where it looks barely better than its decade old predecessor.
But the real travisty here is that if you simply install windows on your mac, without changing the hardware in any way, it runs great at medium quality settings!! I have XP SP3 installed using boot camp, others have reported similar results with windows 7.
So, with identical hardware, the game simply runs better on windows. Now, this is not a fundamental difference between Direct X and OpenGL (as so many have blamed OpenGL for this) but rather bad programming. Direct3D and OpenGL are different approaches to the same problem and optimizing OGL is very different from D3D (especially where shaders are concerned). Whomever was in charge of porting the game to OpenGL and the Mac did not take the task seriously and has released a dubiously flawed product that has dealt a serious blow to mac gaming, one it doesn't deserve.
But that's besides the point. Just don't waste your time. It's a great game and is best experienced on windows so install boot camp, and play it the right way. No new system required!
I cannot speak for current generation hardware but for my previous generation MacBook Pro (the one with the silver bezel, just prior to the unibody switch) with 4GB of Ram and an 8600M GT video chip (which is admittedly the minimum specs for the mac) it is unplayable ... even at the LOWEST quality settings. Even if it didn't stutter and slow down so much, I wouldn't want to play it at the lowest quality settings where it looks barely better than its decade old predecessor.
But the real travisty here is that if you simply install windows on your mac, without changing the hardware in any way, it runs great at medium quality settings!! I have XP SP3 installed using boot camp, others have reported similar results with windows 7.
So, with identical hardware, the game simply runs better on windows. Now, this is not a fundamental difference between Direct X and OpenGL (as so many have blamed OpenGL for this) but rather bad programming. Direct3D and OpenGL are different approaches to the same problem and optimizing OGL is very different from D3D (especially where shaders are concerned). Whomever was in charge of porting the game to OpenGL and the Mac did not take the task seriously and has released a dubiously flawed product that has dealt a serious blow to mac gaming, one it doesn't deserve.
But that's besides the point. Just don't waste your time. It's a great game and is best experienced on windows so install boot camp, and play it the right way. No new system required!
More User Reviews
After a 12 year wait, Starcraft II Gives you one of the Best RTS games ever
Review Stats:- Posted May 27, 2012 11:22 pm GMT
Great Game! Epic singleplayer, epic multiplayer
Review Stats:- 1 user agrees with this review
- Posted Aug 3, 2010 3:33 am GMT
Starcraft 2 is without a doubt, what every RTS wants to be.
Review Stats:- Posted Aug 2, 2010 4:53 am GMT
New Macs play the game just fine under Snow Leopard, no difference whatsoever between the windows version in bootcamp!
Review Stats:- 3 users agree with this review
- Posted Jul 30, 2010 12:18 pm GMT
Leopard is crippled! Give it the boot (camp).
Review Stats:- 3 out of 10 users agree with this review
- Posted Jul 28, 2010 6:44 pm GMT
User Videos
-
I unbox Starcraft 2: Wings of Liberty. (Its theme song is owned by (Activision) Blizzard, not me.)Posted Jan 3, 2011
by tjoeb123 | 9:17 | 495 Views -
Speed run for Protoss Mission 5 (Choosing Sides) of StarCraft. Done by Philip 'ballofsnow' Cornell in 0:43Posted Jun 11, 2007
by Devouring_One | 0:53 | 1,694 Views
User Images
- This is fan art not done by me showing a Firebat with a Hydralisk head impaled by a stake.Posted Aug 6, 2007
by Devouring_One | 9,434 Views
Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty
Not Following
- Publisher(s): Blizzard Entertainment
- Genre: Strategy
- Release:
- PEGI: 16+
Also on:
Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty Navigation
Games You May Like


Remember Me (X360)
The Elder Scrolls Online (MAC)
The Last of Us (PS3)
Beyond: Two Souls (PS3)
Battlefield 4 (PC)
Users who looked at content for this game also looked at these games.


