Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Review

loading...

Game Emblems

The Good

  1. Oblivion Surpassed, With Nordic Lore and A Much In-Depth Story-line and World To Explore

Kevin VanOrd
Posted by Kevin VanOrd, Senior Editor
on

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is the big, bold, and beautiful sequel you hoped for and is sure to bewitch you for countless hours.

That doesn't mean that you don't wield manual control over how you progress. Each time you gain a level, you choose to enhance one of your three main attributes: health, stamina, or magicka. You also earn a single point to spend on a perk, which might increase damage done with axes or let you conjure creatures at a greater distance. It's a great leveling system that forms around the way you play, but allows for tweaking so that you retain a sense of control. Even just the act of leveling up can be a pleasure due to the slick and colorful interface that imagines perks as stars in constellations. It can be a pain to navigate to certain perks; the game often has you flitting not to the star you want, but to all the ones surrounding it. But considering Oblivion's cumbersome interface, Skyrim's is a much improved beast. On console (and if you play with a controller on the PC), thumbstick navigation minimizes button presses, and you can easily move between your quest log and the main map. Additionally, you can mark weapons, spells, and items as favorites and then access them quickly during combat. Certain aspects might be fiddly, but on the whole, Skyrim's interface is a wonder, considering how much information and inventory is at your fingertips.

Companions are good to have. But they all too often have minds of their own.

Regardless of how you tailor your character, the action is entertaining and varied. Trolls, undead draugrs, necromancers, bandits, witches, ratlike skeevers, and many more foes want to make your hero a zero. You occasionally feel as if you're flailing blindly rather than connecting your sharp blade with a vampire's flesh. But this is the tightest Elder Scrolls combat yet, the visual and audio cues normally providing proper feedback with your blows and zaps. Some death blows result in Fallout 3-style slow-motion kills, which retain their power because they're not overly frequent. Movement, too, has seen improvement: you can now play from a third-person view and feel like you're moving across the land instead of floating above it. What hasn't been improved is the friendly AI. It's nice to have a companion along for the adventure, and you're given one for free early in the story. But companions are morons, crowding you in tight passages, lagging behind when you need them the most, and even getting stuck in various death loops caused by spinning blade traps.

If you're the stealthy type, you can sneak about, picking pockets and breaking into homes. If you really enjoy keeping to the shadows, you may even wish to contract porphyric hemophilia--that is, vampirism. Vampires earn some benefits by way of certain spells and status effects, but also endure particular risks and must feed on unsuspecting victims as they slumber. But even if you like to wade directly into the fray, you can benefit from Skyrim's non-combat activities. Lock-picking no longer works as it did in Oblivion, but takes its cue from Fallout 3, having you rotate a lock pick and turn the lock to determine how closely you matched the correct position. As before, you can pick flowers and collect ingredients, and then create potions out of them at an alchemy table. (Forget mortars and pestles this time around.) And any adventurer can benefit from enchanting, which lets you imbue your equipment with certain status effects--though you must use soul gems to recharge their power.

Many of Skyrim's delights are the touches that occur outside of the action. Citizens go about their daily lives, selling their wares in shops during the day and closing down at night to hang out in the pub or head home to rest. Under some circumstances, they may comment on your rancid breath or remark on how sickly you seem to look. Children run up and down the streets; one may even ask for you to stop a bully from picking on him. Citizens move somewhat stiffly, but with more grace than in previous Elder Scrolls games. Before, conversations brought the world to a halt and focused the camera on some character's waxy face. In Skyrim, certain dialogues limit the camera and temporarily paralyze you in place, but overall, conversations feel more organic than before--a nice improvement that enhances your sense of immersion.

Skyrim also uses scattered books and references to enthrall you. You may not be a big fan of reading books in role-playing games, but even so, you should make an effort here. If you don't feel like reading up on Tamriel's rich history each time you find a volume, grab it and read it later--there are a lot of narrative tidbits that deserve to be read. Elder Scrolls fans will appreciate nods to events in prior games, and everyone can enjoy the bite-size tales contained therein, about vampires, noble heroes, and gods that bestow their blessings on their followers. Skyrim takes place hundreds of years after the events of Oblivion, and organizations you might remember have been restructured or are shadows of their former selves. But Tamriel's history is threaded throughout Skyrim's fabric, and some quests, such as one that begins with an invitation to a faraway museum, are great reminders of past misfortunes that the world has not forgotten.

It's a pity that Skyrim often breaks the immersion it tries so hard to create, in ways both minor and major. Some bizarre details are simply annoying. A character might initiate conversation through the ceiling. The chatter of nearby characters could drown out important story exposition. Two shopkeepers standing next to each other may be voiced by the same actor and repeat the same lines. A dragon skeleton might disappear and then later drop out of the sky in a new location. A dragon could get stuck in place, flailing about in the geometry in a mess of wings and tail. For that matter, you could get stuck in the environment, maybe just by walking into a corner, which forces you to either quick-travel to a different location (if you're lucky enough to be outdoors) or load a save game. Frame rate drops are uncommon, but you might encounter a few severe ones, and Xbox 360 system crashes might occur. The question isn't whether you will experience anomalies--it's a given. The question is: which ones and how many?

If you've played previous Elder Scrolls games, glitches and oddities don't come as a surprise. Nevertheless, Skyrim comes in a year graced with multiple quality RPGs that feature tighter combat, fewer bugs, better animations, and so forth. But to be fair, none of those games are endowed with such enormity. Yet The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim doesn't rely on sheer scope to earn its stripes. It isn't just that there's a lot to do: it's that most of it is so good. Whether you're slashing a dragon's wings, raising the dead back to life, or experimenting at the alchemy table, Skyrim performs the most spectacular of enchantments: the one that causes huge chunks of time to vanish before you know it.

Kevin VanOrd
By Kevin VanOrd, Senior Editor

Kevin VanOrd is a lifelong RPG lover and violin player. When he isn't busy building PCs and composing symphonies, he watches American Dad reruns with his fat cat, Ollie.

139 comments
B_STATS
B_STATS like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Over ambitious and as a result, super buggy. It is becoming increasingly evident that Bethesda is attempting to create next generation games on current gen consoles. The sad thing is they are only going to try and add even more and continue to release bugged games when the next gen finally does come around.

And the public were the official beta testers for Skyrim.

The game is huge and rich with lore and content but 9 or so patches later and it still suffers terribly from bugs. Especially the infamous ash piles that have been 'fixed' 3 times yet still never disappear even on a new game.

It gains points for being First Person though. I HATE Third Person games with a passion, they always feel so impersonal. Third person and immersion? Impossible.

Ultimately Skyrim is like the girl you desperately love but she keeps f#cking other guys behind your back and ends up giving you the clap

coolmath4life
coolmath4life like.author.displayName 1 Like

Skyrim in a nutshell, Huge open landscape, limited interaction, play-rewind mechanics, meaning you go to a dungeon,cave,temple,fortress, kill the monsters,bad guys, loot, rinse and repeat, as for story, sucks. too generic, never wanted to finish it, and didn't feel like I made a difference when I did. DLC, dumb, why give me the power to build a house, then only have a few plots of land to put it on, I wanted mine on top of a F*****G mountain! Never ran into any glitches... Honestly I could care less for Skyrim, Elder Scrolls Oblivion was better in my book. Nothing is structured, its like go anywhere and do whatever you want. but do what exactly, I have a huge world and all i can do is swing my sword and pick S**T up? Kill-Loot-Repeat. The world is good looking don't get me wrong, its just I couldn't get into this at all compared to Oblivion - Morrowind. And I'm a big Elder Scrolls fan, Day one purchase! But oh well maybe next one will be good. or possibly Fallout 4, structured like the story in New Vegas, because obsidian is way better at story telling than Betheseda. For now ill stick with my Dark Souls... Now that's a great game (LOST3500) If anyone wants to duel in the Souls that's my gamertag! Peace!

williebazerka
williebazerka

@coolmath4life I disagree about Skyrim probably because I love it.But I agree with everything else.Especially Dark Souls.I'm still trying to beat it for the first time.Just taking me along time but I'll keep trying.

Dannystaples14
Dannystaples14

I came here after several attempts at starting this game only to get bored and stop playing. I listen to the review and agree with most of it. Great scenery, choice, open world, plenty to explore. But I keep thinking that is all good but I still don't want to play this game. There is something seriously missing, and I am a massive RPG fan. It is the only type of game I can truly lose myself in. I don't find it hard to turn Skyrim off though, in fact most of the time I find it hard not to turn it off. I just feel this is more the idea of them saying, "Here is a massive world for you to explore." and that is that. They tack some story onto the game but overall it is just you wandering through caves and for what? So you can go search more caves? There has to be something holding you in the world you are exploring and I haven't found what it is yet. If I don't find it soon I doubt I will be bothered to find out what it is.

Paoksis
Paoksis

@Dannystaples14 the lack of a strong central plot possibly...it has everything else except that

goriv
goriv

 hey guys,which is better in the RPG world? dragon age series? dark souls series? or the witcher series? not to mention skyrim because im biased to skyrim! SKYRIM is the BEST!!

coolmath4life
coolmath4life like.author.displayName 1 Like

@goriv I'd Recommend Dark souls, not much story telling, but better than skyrim's lol. You are the story in Dark Souls. Great game, Great Difficulty, Give you that Sense of accomplishment when you beat a boss. Or get a better weapon ext... I world highly recommend you try it. LOST3500 is my gamertag if you do. add me and we can co op some bosses. Peace!


Paoksis
Paoksis

@goriv 

dragon age is a modern old school rpg with more emphasis on tactics,while witcher has more fluid combat....dark souls is in same combat style as witcher except 10x harder and a darker world....if you like amazing epic story go for DA,if you like epic story with stylish combat and graphics go for Witcher,if you like to experience a very dark and cruel world go for DS

Devil_78
Devil_78

@goriv skyrim have the biggest world . But if you want a very good story play dragon age . If you want a very challenging old school game play dark soul . For me dragon age 1 and oblivion are the best of the best .

NTM23
NTM23

I have a problem with this game. I find it really boring a lot of the time, and I try not to; mostly when there are conversations between the characters and I. The biggest problem I have with the game isn't necessarily the bugs in the game, it's the character animations that take me out of the immersion; in general, whether that be facial or body. The greatest thing the game can do is put you in the wilderness; it's somewhat calming.

I have yet to beat it of course, as well as hours and hours of side missions. That's just my personal take on it from all that I have done in the game, which is merely a few hours in, without much of the story. I can't really put too much criticism towards it since I haven't experienced all that can be experienced, but from the few hours I've played of it, I know what I can say about the things I have played, and I feel I know what to expect.

There is quite a lot of positive stuff to say, but my problems outweigh the positives, though not through quantity, but through quality. I wish when it comes to next-gen, when they make an Elder Scrolls game, they keep the world as large as Skyrim, at most, but work on the animations; character interactions (not necessarily from a dialogue or voice acting perspective), and just an overall graphics update; I think that'll help me become a lot more immersed in the world, which is one of the large attractions of Elder Scrolls games I believe.

I know many people can look past these things, but it's not something that I can be okay with. If I'm not immersed one way or another, I'm bored. I don't own this game, I am now, and again, borrowing it from my brother. I just turned it off, and I have to say that it was a bit more bearable. As long as I have no agenda with other games, and I can sit down and enjoy this, I think it'll help; unfortunately, now that won't be possible. I just got Crysis 3. 

Divad222
Divad222

I had a blast playing through Skyrim. The complaints I have are the amount of bugs plaguing the game and the really low difficulty. Skyrim was just was too easy. Tho all and all I really the enjoyed the game

holyfs
holyfs

looooooooooong live skyrim

 

gameguy34
gameguy34

I think skyrim is an overall great game. I could play it for hours. I like the overall controls and the easy navigation from spell to item. this game isnt perfect though. I do not like the long loading time, it is excessive and takes away from the game. The loading time is so ridiculusly long that after a while I dont really want to play anymore.. And I also do not like the frequent glitches. You get stuck in rivers and rocks and buildings, it gets to the point where you have go to the last checkpoint after all the progress you have made throughout the game. Other than those things I think it is a great game. It is the first elder scrolls game I have played, i like the series and am looking forward to an other.

mjaddo
mjaddo

one of the greatest games of all time no debate about that.

 

JackHarker
JackHarker like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

I don't see why people are praising this game, I thought there was nothing fun about it. To me, oblivion was the best game I have ever played (along with Fallout 3) so I was very excited for this game, so it was a HUGE disappointment for me. But everyone has their own opinion, it just makes me wonder because I have never met anyone who dislikes this.

williebazerka
williebazerka

@JackHarker I love all the games you mentioned.I usually spend all my time just walking around exploring the worlds and doing my own thing.I don't even pay attention to the story.Oblivion is the game I've spent the least amount of time with out of F3,Skyrim and Oblivion but I will eventually spend hundreds of hours there too like the others.I have hundreds of hours in Skyrim and still haven't been to that underground city with the crystals.I always get side tracked.F3 is still my favorite if I had to pick.

jchristenberry
jchristenberry like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @JackHarker I liked them both, but saw this one as a vast improvement in its simplification of the menus and lack of annoying fish eye lense.  That always bugged me about oblivion, everyone looked like that had fat wide faces because of the camera.  I couldnt stick it out with oblivion although it was a stunning game.  Skyrim however i find myself continuing to pick it up again and again!

armeezy
armeezy like.author.displayName 1 Like

This game is ridiculously dope. hands down!

slimskelter
slimskelter

I look at the review and user scores and can't believe there are this many gamers who are willing to overlook so many bugs, and I'm not talking about graphical glitches, I mean spending hours on a quest only to not be able to finish it because of some programmer error. Having to kill an important player because of a character programming glitch. It goes on and on and on. Don't get me wrong, this would definitely deserve this much praise if it wasn't so frustratingly flawed. I played to level 48 and completed the Dragonslayer quest along with most of the major quests and 65% of the side quests. I stayed neutral as long as I could but eventually had to choose a side, so I joined the Stormcloaks, however I'd had it with the bugs and quit before taking part in the civil war. I played a great deal of the game. It's one thing to get frustrated with a game because it's difficult, if fairly so. That's just gaming 101. I think people are stuck in some sort of denial induced by the hype of the game. When everything is going AS IT SHOULD this game is f'ing great, way to easy, but great. Not worth $60. Wait till it comes down to half that, and you won't feel cheated.

gameguy34
gameguy34

@slimskelter I agree the bugs are a big problem. I think bethesda should release an update to fix them.

j1965
j1965 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Having a blast with this game more then Dark souls!So much to do!

juiceair
juiceair like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 7 Like

 @j1965 Dark Souls is overrated and after completing both games, it's not even close.  Skyrim>DS by a mile.

asolec
asolec like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Dawnguard is a great addition to skyrim. I did the vampire story line and had lots of fun playing as the lord vampire. If you don't mind having to feed once a day I strongly recommend that story line. If you are a werewolf you can always go back to being the werewolf after you are done feeding on the humans. :P

djdanf
djdanf like.author.displayName 1 Like

Skyrim is a game of skill you will know if you have played oblivion, you start of as a convict ready to get exicuted wich i didnt really get, you will really enjoy this game if you liked the fallout games, if you never played any of the elderscrolls or fallout i really recomend it and the add on dawngaurd is really good just make sure you ether have a good level or good armour or wepons thanks.

 

adk4e
adk4e

this is a good game , but from a guy who played fallout. its just...

the thing that was so great in fallout is that you can create your own story, skyrim gives you that feeling but in skyrim you dont really have any choise.

 

so its a good game but the lack of choise for this kind of game bugs me

124C1
124C1 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Skyrim is "Twilight" for boys. And seeing this casual half-done game getting such a high score just amazes me. Gamespot, sometimes You are so inadequate.

 

P.S. Epic dragon Battles are so "epic", lol (Went playing MH and waiting Dark Souls for PC)

mattsp10
mattsp10

 @124C1 I agree with you, but Skyrim is still is very well-made game.  The dragon battles are most certainly not epic.  I can 100% agree with that, but it's still a fantastic adventure..  Dark souls won my GoTY vote.  If Skyrim wasn't main-stream, it would have never won GoTY.

124C1
124C1

 @mattsp10 

Well-made? I can agree with the point that it took much resources.

 

Dragon Batlles - Epic? oh COME ON, when even Guards could take them out. When These dragons fly around, go down to get their portion of hp damage with shitty animation, doing nothing, then flying away so U could heal? Yeah, it just can't get any cooler than this.

 

Dragon fights from MH games are surely not that epic, uh-huh.

And Dark Souls. just some clicking, right?

 

Not everything that wins GOTY is a good game indeed, it's just pick of some people, and today's game industry is full of wastes.

Sadly, "pieces of art" tend to be manipulative at some times. So RPG about so manly nords, fighting dragons IS manipulative.

mattsp10
mattsp10

 @124C1 and what the hell do you mean by "just clicking"?  You do that in every friggin game, haha..

mattsp10
mattsp10

 @124C1 What?  I said skyrim dragon battles are NOT epic.  Skyrim combat is VERY dull.  The boss design and tension of the battles in Dark Souls is what makes them so epic.

DanDreadblood
DanDreadblood like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 4 Like

Who thinks that he should do another review but including mods.

Joeskinis
Joeskinis

sweet! I've just received my free minecraft giftcode! >>minecraft.info

slayerzomby1994
slayerzomby1994 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

It was a great game, until I got a lot of bugs in quests making them unfinishable(does this word exist??)

hamebone123
hamebone123 like.author.displayName 1 Like

they give it a 9.....and yet it will most likely beat out gears of war 3 and dark souls (which both got a 9.5) and win game of the year....doesn't make much sense to me.

mattsp10
mattsp10 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @hamebone123 Skyrim only won GoTY because it's mainstream... Dark Souls deserves the 9.5... A 9 for Skyrim is very generous.

hamebone123
hamebone123 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @mattsp10 dark souls is great too. i'm glad it got a 9.5 as well...but one of the main reasons most publishers didn't give it  game of the year is because most of them were put off by how hard it is and never gave it a chance. If dark souls won game of the year...you wouldn't hear me complaining about it one bit.

vyaswanth
vyaswanth

 @hamebone123  @mattsp10 I don't think dark souls is hard and few boss battles are hard, and enemies in dark souls has terrible AI compared to skyrim.

In skyrim if we sneak attack they will search for us and leaves us after a while but in dark souls if enemies are hit from a certain distance they won't even bother that they are being hit.

hamebone123
hamebone123

 @mattsp10 yeah. That's what i meant. I wish dark souls won but i'm not mad at skyrim because both games are very different but they're also great in their own ways.

mattsp10
mattsp10 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

 @hamebone123 Well said.  100% agree with you.   It's not even the difficulty for me.  Dark Souls requires thought and concentration.  Once you learn the basics, it becomes one hell of a ride.  I still like Skyrim, but Dark Souls takes the cake, for me.

Lord_Python1049
Lord_Python1049

 @hamebone123 Game of the year isn't the game that gets the highest score, but the game that made that year what it was, and a lot of other reasons they put forth in one of the videos. Demon Souls got game of the year with a 9 as well.

hamebone123
hamebone123 like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @Lord_Python1049 I agree...it should win goty, what i meant was that they should have given it a higher rating. if they watied on reviewing skyrim until the patches were created then it would have gotten a higher score since the biggest issue was the "game breaking bugs"

smackybear
smackybear like.author.displayName 1 Like

Dull, brain-dead combat kills this game for me.

bf3rocks23
bf3rocks23

looks like a challenge to create, but so manny things to put into it.

bf3rocks23
bf3rocks23 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Very creative, very well put together.

Conversation powered by Livefyre