Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

Thief: Deadly Shadows User Review

Edele_Wilde

It's broken.

  • Posted Nov 3, 2006 12:57 pm GMT
  • Recommended by 1 of 4 users.
Gameplay
5
Graphics
7
Sound
9
Value
5
Tilt
6
Difficulty:
Very Easy
Learning Curve:
0 to 30 Minutes
Time Spent:
20 to 40 Hours
The Bottom Line:
"Uninspired"
Now what the fork is up with this game. The first two are the best games I have ever played, when everyone was raving about a pretty decent shooter called half-life I was immersing myselve it the greatest gameworld ever created, huge realistic levels, seemingly filled with life, you could almost touch the walls and smell the weird medieval town. Ambient sounds dripping with atmosphere, the first step towards having real physics (oh the first time I fired that bow, I was amazed) and last but not least, an AI that was no less then revolutionary, they actually searched for you, absolutily unheard of. Well that leaves us with Deadly Shadows, a game based on the games I just described, calling it a sequel I won 't do; Deadly Shadows is merely a game based on Thief. It isn't even a bad game per se, actually it is pretty decent compared to wannabe's like the Splinter Cell's. But decent won't do for my most beloved Thief. So many things wrong with this title. Let's start with what they did right, they hired the same voiceactor, and the ambient music is once again excellent. Oh, and the Cradle should be considered the magnus opus of videogame creation, it's nothing short of brilliant. But there is soooooooo much soooooo wrong. The levels are small, the loading times are long, just the 'Ambushed' mission of Thief 2 is bigger then the entire city of DS, much bigger. The AI is broken, sure they will say 'why not look there in the shadows', but it 's all windowdressing that serves nothing but the immersion, the immersion that you don't there because of so many small annoyances and baffling design decisions (climbing gloves? what was wrong with the rope arrow? And why can't I swim? Who put glue on my feet?). The physcis don't feel solid. Unlike the previous game you don't feel like you are pulling the string of a bow, and are actually firing a solid object. When you blackjack someone it looks as if you dropped a battlecruiser on their heads, and that before your hit connects. Nothing seems to have any real weight, this is how people with mechanical arms must feel. It's not just the gameplay, sooo much sloppyness. What happened to the moody handdrawn briefings you got before the missions, I really missed those. This game has dissapointed me on so many levels. If you never played the previous titles, go ahead, you will probably like Deadly Shadows for what it is. But I can't like because of what it isn't, a true sequel to my favorite game ever made.
Rate this Review:

More User Reviews

  1. Thief: Deadly Shadows, a game with a good story good controls and a few minor technical issues.

    Review Stats:
  2. This game is one of the best games in the game series.Not only can you stab someone but hit them with a blackjack.

    Review Stats:
    • 0 out of 1 users agree with this review
  3. Garret is back! and (with the exeption of a few glitches) is still one of the best stealth games around....

    Review Stats:
    • 1 user agrees with this review
  4. Ahh... Garret returns to the third and final Thief installment with a new arsenal, a great storyline and alot of quests.

    Review Stats:
    • 1 user agrees with this review
  5. Thief: Deadly shadows... a well worth playing game that suffers from a few minor technical issues.

    Review Stats:
    • 1 out of 2 users agrees with this review

Tell the world what you think of Thief: Deadly Shadows.

User Videos

  1. Watch this video
    It's very dark..hard to see.But it is a speedy run none-the-less.
    Posted Mar 24, 2009
    by Chirodip_08 | 2:59 | 1,686 Views
  2. Watch this video
    Warning: Includes SPOILERS! Just a little video I made using the cutscenes of "Thief - The Dark Project" and "Thief - The Metal Age", two of the absolute best games ever released and the great song "Sleep now" by Hughes Ha
    Posted Apr 13, 2007
    by Xerosch | 2:11 | 1,704 Views

User Images

  1. thief4
    Posted Sep 20, 2010
    by MR_HITMAN22 | 129 Views
  2. Wallpaper that came with 'Thief Gold'. Kudos to Eidos.
    Posted Jun 21, 2007
    by AbiKessler | 4,149 Views

Thief: Deadly Shadows BoxshotEnlarge the boxshot
Not Following

    Game Stats

    Also on:

    Games You May Like

    Users who looked at content for this game also looked at these games.